Re: Response

["Benedict" <boycat_oh@...>]

Hi, Eric

I am not sure I fully understand the problem you have with this 
contest rule.

As the judge of the latest contest I would like to make an effort to 
try and understand, as I would hate for this to be revisited in 
January.  

How about if i ask a question that may look at this in a different 
way:

How, in your opinion, does Pharaoh's Heir not comply with this 
rule?

Thanks
Phillip

> "The game must utilize a piecepack and preferably should 
> make use of some of the unique aspects of the piecepack."
> 
>  Apparently I was confused by this myself, before the judging. 
> 
>  I then offered my perception of what happened.  And as I 
asked, 
> have been corrected. 
> 
>  Obviously some members dont think along the same lines as 
I do. 
> This should not keep my thoughts away from the group. Let me 
be 
> clear and understood on this; I found the last contest slightly 
> hypocritical. Again, I may have used sharp words to express 
my take 
> on the entire situation. It was a situation regardless of how I 
> responded.(it was also a situation if I didn't respond). 
Piecepack 
> being a different and realatively new format can excel with new 
and 
> unique ideas as well as old standards.